Some critics claim that Jim is Huck’s “true father.” Defend or refute this statement.
After reading the book and used some time to think about it, I would first like to start with saying that this book is much shorter and have less details then the film and the cartoons which went on TV a few years back. But then again, the book is a “beginner” book and is probably made for children at a younger age.
And when that is said. We all know now that if we had seen the film or the cartoons we would probably get another view of the story and on the question if Jim is Huck’s ”true father” or not since the film and the cartoons have more details and so on.
But lets not only talk about Jim as well, we also need to talk about Huck’s biological father, which is Mr. Finn. Mr. Finn is a very bad, selfish, drunk and dirty person that only thinks about himself and what’s best for him. Mr. Finn is usually drunk all the time and always hit and curse at poor Huck. And when Huck’s mum died when he was young Mr. Finn left him all alone. Which is very bad. The only times Mr. Finn comes back to Huck is whenever he needs something, like money for an instance.
And when we know all these facts, we kinda get another perspective of the questions. In my opinion we can already say that Mr. Finn wasn’t a dad at all though he was the biological dad, because who wants a “dad” that hits you, curse at you and is always drunk and only comes to you when he needs money? NO! No one wants their dad to be like that, which kinda lead us back to Jim. Is he the “true father” or not?
Well.. I would say both yes and no. why? Well, simply because they kinda both are “fathers” to each others in one or the other way in my opinion. The reason I’m saying this is because they both look out for each other, they are more like brothers, so I would rather call them for brothers because they both care for each other very much.
Examples for this is like the time Jim and Huck was going down the river on their raft and were going past the place called St. Louis. Jim was asking why the place was called St. Louis, and since Huck knew the answers he told him. And all such things happened quite often on their journey. Whenever Jim was insecure he always asked Huck for answers and advice because he knew that Huck had studied at school, which Jim has not since he’s a slave. And even if he did study he would probably study in his homeland, Africa. And I guess that they didn’t learn so much about American places and stuff on the schools in Africa back then anyway…
This is only an example on how Huck took care of Jim.
Examples on the opposite, that Jim also took care of Huck:
In the book, you get to read about a big flood. Huck and Jim took the canoe and started to search around the mess such as destroyed houses, huts, wagons and so on that was caused by the flood. They eventually found a tree hut and Jim carefully went through one of the windows so he could get inside the hut in hope to find valuables such as money. Jim quickly saw Huck’s dad dead in the hut and therefore refused to let Huck go inside because he didn’t want Huck to see his dad dead since it could hurt him. In my opinion though, hiding Mr. Finn’s dead body from Huck wasn’t necessary. Huck hated his father so much anyway because he got hit and cursed on by him, Huck was probably scared and hated him so much, that letting him see his dad that would maybe make him happier, because then he didn’t have so much to fear. But that is just my thoughts. But in general this deed was a very good thing to do and is a good example on that Jim is taking care of Huck and only wants the best for him.
So back to the question once again. Is Jim Huck’s “true father”, and what about Mr. Finn? I would indeed say that Mr. Finn was not the one taking the dad-role, it was Jim. Jim and Huck and more in common then Mr. Finn had with Huck. Together on their trip Jim and Huck grew a tight bond, a friendship that was built on trust and compassion. They always had the same thoughts and whenever one of them got in trouble the other was always there for him to help him out and support him no matter what. So it would only be natural for me to say that Jim WAS Huck’s “true father”, in other words I defend the statement though I would rather call them brothers.